My Dearest Gentle Reader,
There are certain shows one returns to the way one returns to a favourite pub: not because one expects novelty, but because one expects warmth. Familiarity. A sense of being welcomed back into a space that remembers you. And so it was with The Choir of Man, a show I first encountered when it tumbled out of the Edinburgh Fringe and into London with the chaotic enthusiasm of a golden retriever who has just discovered a new park.
Seeing it again, years later, felt like stepping back into a room where the chairs have been rearranged, the lighting has softened, and the stories have deepened — but the heart of the place remains exactly the same.
I arrived with my partner and family in tow — a multigenerational, multi‑interest ensemble cast and yet somehow, miraculously, The Choir of Man managed to charm every single one of us, in different ways. It is, I have decided, the theatrical equivalent of a universal remote: it works for everyone, even those who swear they don’t like musicals.
The premise is simple: a pub called The Jungle, nine men, a live band, and a collection of songs and stories stitched together with more heart than plot. But simplicity is deceptive. Beneath the laughter, the banter, and the occasional flying packet of crisps or ping pong ball lies something tender — a meditation on community, vulnerability, and the quiet ways we hold each other together.
The show begins before it begins. The cast wander through the audience, chatting, laughing, handing out pints, and generally behaving like the world’s most charismatic pub staff. It is disarming in the best way. Theatre, they seem to say, is not something that happens to you. It is something we build together. And in that moment — pint in hand, strangers smiling at one another — I believed them.
Then the music starts, and the room shifts.
There is something about a group of men singing in harmony that hits harder than one expects. Perhaps it is the rarity of seeing men allowed to be emotional without apology. Perhaps it is the sheer joy of voices blending in a way that feels like a hug. Or perhaps it is simply that the show is very, very good at sneaking up on you.
I laughed — loudly, inelegantly, without restraint. Their rendition of “Escape (The Piña Colada Song)” nearly ended me. I have never witnessed such committed, joyful absurdity. It was like watching a group of grown men discover the concept of chaos for the first time and immediately decide to major in it.
And then, without warning, the show pivoted. “Dance With My Father” arrived like a quiet confession, and suddenly the room was holding its breath. The Poet’s monologues — delivered with devastating gentleness — tied everything together, reminding us that beneath the jokes and the pints and the tap‑dancing lies something deeper: the need to be seen. To be heard. To be held.
It is this balance — the laughter that makes the heartbreak sharper, the heartbreak that makes the laughter sweeter — that defines The Choir of Man. It is a show that understands that joy and sorrow are not opposites, but companions.
And speaking of companions: Barnabas attended.
Not intentionally. He slipped in during the interval, perched himself in the rafters, and proceeded to observe the proceedings with the air of a critic who has seen better choreography in the park. I spent the second half of the show praying he would remain silent. He did not. At one point, during a particularly emotional harmony, he let out a soft coo that sounded suspiciously like, “You call that a crescendo?”
Mortifying.
By the finale, he was convinced he could have improved the choreography. I have no doubt he will be insufferable for weeks.
But let us talk about pubs.
Because The Choir of Man is not just a show about a pub. It is a show about what pubs mean. And this, dear reader, is where my heart cracked a little.
Pubs are not merely places to drink. They are places to gather. To laugh. To cry. To sit quietly with a coffee and a packet of crisps and feel, for a moment, less alone. They are community centres disguised as drinking establishments. They are living rooms for people who don’t have living rooms big enough to hold their lives.
And they are disappearing.
One by one, the lights go out. The beer gardens fall silent. The quiz nights fade. The karaoke machines gather dust. The live bands lose another stage. And the spaces where people once found connection — real, messy, human connection — shrink.
The show reminded me of this. It reminded me that if we want pubs to survive, we must show up. Not just for pints, but for people. For quiz nights. For karaoke. For live bands. For the simple act of being together. Even in Dry January. Even when all you want is a coffee and a quiet corner.
Because community does not happen by accident. It happens by attendance.
And then there is the matter of men’s mental health.
The show does not preach. It does not lecture. It simply opens a door and invites you to look inside. To see the loneliness that hides behind jokes. To see the vulnerability that hides behind bravado. To see the quiet ache that so many men carry because they have been told — explicitly or implicitly — that their feelings are inconvenient.
I am, as you know, a staunch egalitarian. I will fight for women’s rights until the end of the earth and back, but I will never call myself a feminist. I believe in equality — not in one direction, but in all directions. And part of equality is acknowledging that men, too, need space to open up. To speak. To feel. To be held without judgment.
The Choir of Man supports CALM — Campaign Against Living Miserably, a charity dedicated to preventing suicide and supporting men in crisis. Their work is vital, compassionate, and deeply aligned with the heart of the show.
You can learn more or donate here: https://www.thecalmzone.net
The show’s partnership with CALM is not a footnote. It is a lifeline woven into the fabric of the performance. A reminder that community is not just about laughter — it is about care.
By the time the final song arrived, the room was glowing. Not with stage lights, but with something softer. Something communal. Something like hope.
I left the theatre feeling lighter and heavier all at once — the way one feels after a good cry and a good laugh in the same hour. My partner was beaming. The family was buzzing. Barnabas was critiquing the lighting design. And I was reminded, once again, that theatre — like pubs — is a place where we gather to remember we are human.
Five stars. One pint. Several unexpected feelings.
Lady Eversea









