Rating: ** (2/5)
Published: Emily Bestler Books, June 2026
Format: ARC
Genre: Mystery
Source: Publisher
Ten years ago, a group of Jewish kids and their counselors were camping on an Azores island when one of them went missing. The police have been unable to determine what happened to Sydney, and a decade later, everyone involved returns to the island for a memorial at the local synagogue. Since everyone is together again for the first time since Sydney’s disappearance, counselor Jules aspires to make a true crime documentary and interviews everyone who was present on their camping trip.
I don’t think the whole documentary transcript format fit with the rest of the narrative. It led to everyone arguing about their memories and motives and didn’t feel cohesive. Then there’s the whole hidden treasure hunt thing that convoluted the latter part of the book. It was terribly cliched how the villain spent chapters monologuing their crimes to their intended victims before dispensing of them. Considering all the revelations, I was very disappointed in the ambiguous ending. If it hadn’t ended so abruptly, I might have given it three starts. The final third of the book was altogether too messy. Between all the bickering and blaming, it was a tedious affair with an unsatisfactory conclusion.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher.










