Evan has always been a great sleeper. He used to wake up only once to eat, and when we got rid of that feeding, he started sleeping all night, 11-12 hrs per night, plus his two 1-2 hr naps. As any kid, he would get crappy sleep when teething, but after the teething episode was done, so were the sleeping problems: he would go back to his normal schedule. He learned to put himself to sleep since he was a baby, and we completely faced out any rocking and feeding to sleep long time ago. I would put him down still awake, and he would turn and fall asleep.
Right now it's a whole different story. About three weeks ago he started refusing one of his naps. Not every day, but often. We've been there before, especially during teething, and he always goes back to his two nap schedule after a few days. But this time he started napping worse, and after a very good streak of no night wakings at all for something like two consecutive weeks, he started waking up at night. When he wakes up screaming, it's usually nightmares, so we used to go, give him a hug and put him back down, and he used to go back to sleep.
No more. Somehow we got sucked into staying in his room until he fell asleep, and now he won't have it any other way. At first it was only at bedtime, but it was also during any night waking (which as I mentioned, became far more regular), and finally nap time as well. So EVERY time he goes to sleep.
And when he wakes up at night, it can take a couple of hours for us to be able to leave his room. Sometimes he goes back to sleep, but wakes up every half hour or so, so we end up back there sooner rather than later. But other nights, the really bad nights, he won't go to sleep for hours. He's just checking on us, making sure we're still there, every few minutes.
In a moment of desperation, we tried to let him cry it out, though I'm really opposed to it. Maybe you're one of those who think it won't work if you don't believe in it. That's fine, but we really tried, and it still didn't work. Four nights we let him cry and cry, and four nights he cried and screamed for almost 4 hours.
So, ok, perhaps we didn't do it right. The first night, after 3.5 hours, DH grabbed him and slept with him in the guest bed... The second night we finally stayed in the room for the 2 minutes it took him to fall asleep. But the third night I only went in once, after 2 hours just to check on him, and he finally cried himself to sleep, after over 4 hours. The forth night, after all that crying, Evan had a sore throat, and though we let him cry for another 4 hours, we decided to stop.
So here we are, staying in his room until he falls asleep, even when he wakes up several times at night, and trying to get him into a new one-nap schedule.
Thank goodness Joan sleeps all night. I can't imagine having two kids waking up at night!