
For the past couple of weeks, in between listening to the stories of my friends unravel and spinning a few of my own, I've been reading two books by Stephen Dunn: the Pulitzer prize-winning Different Hours (2000) I finally bought at Aeon, and Arkaye's copy of Insistence of Beauty (2004). I've grown to love his compassionate, truthful voice---though I admit that a few times he tends to verge on the sentimental and trivial, coloring everything with a nostalgic eye. Dunn's strengths are the clarity of his voice, his accessibility (without the jocular glibness of Billy Collins), his earthy and uneasy wisdom. I like his concerns most of all. He said somewhere that "clarity in the service of what is easy to say isn't of interest to me. Clarity in the service of complexity is." The complexities that excite him often lie in the relationship arena: infidelities, the private-public split, the stories and versions of ourselves we tell our friends, lovers, and former selves. His poems' storyteller risks navigating the shadowy areas, untying and tying knots, delighting in (and sometimes romanticizing) ambiguities, always aware that "the reverse side also has a reverse side." So whether he narrates what happened to Jack and Jill after the crown-breaking and tumbling after, or offers a toast to "what goes on" after friends betray each other and get cancer, he remains ambivalent. And doesn't slip into easy confessionalism, believing in Robert Frost's precaution that "we shall be known by the delicacy of where we stop short." Above all, his borrow-able, revise-able stories implicate us readers. His hope, I think, is to lead us to that most human of emotions, empathy, which he defines as
more like a leaning, like being able
to imagine a life for a spider, a maker's
life, or just some aliveness
in its wide abdomen and delicate spinnerets
so you take it outside in two paper cups
instead of stepping on it.
And that empathy can lead us to action, and communion:
I looked for those who didn't laugh
at those of us who fell.
In the barracks, after drills,
the quiet fellowship of the fallen.
* * * * *
The Stories
Stephen Dunn
For M.A.W.
(1939-1994)
I was unfaithful to you last week.
Though I tried to be true
to the beautiful vagaries
of our unauthorized love,
I told a stranger our story,
arranging and rearranging us
until we were orderly, reduced.
I didn't want to sleep with this stranger.
I wanted, I think, to see her yield,
to sense her body's musculature,
her history of sane resistance
become pliable, as yours had
twenty-two years ago.
I told her we met in parks
and rest stops along highways.
Once, deep in the woods,
a blanket over stones and dirt.
I said that you were, finally,
my failure of nerve,
made to the contours of my body,
so wrongly good for me
I had to give you up.
Listening to myself, it seemed
as if I were still inconsolable,
and I knew the seductiveness in that,
knew when she'd try to console me
I'd allow her the tiniest of victories.
I told her about Laguna, the ruins
we made of each other.
To be undone---I said I learned
that's what I'd always wanted.
We were on a train from Boston
to New York, this stranger and I,
the compartment to ourselves.
I don't have to point out to you
the erotics of such a space.
We'd been speaking of our marriages,
the odd triumphs of their durations.
"Once...," I said, and my betrayal began,
and did not end.
She had a story, too.
Mine seemed to coax hers out.
There was this man she'd meet
every workday Thursday at noon.
For three years, every Thursday
except Thanksgiving. She couldn't
bear it anymore, she said,
the lies, the coming home.
Ended, she said.
Happiest years of her life, she said.
At that moment (you understand)
we had to hug, but that's all we did.
It hardly matters. We were in each other's
sanctums, among the keepsakes,
we'd gone where most sex cannot go.
I could say that telling her our story
was a way of bringing you back to life,
and for a while it was, a memorial
made of memory and its words.
But here's what I knew:
Watching her react, I was sure I'd tell
our story again, to others. I understood
how it could be taken to the bank,
and I feared I might not ever again
feel enough to know when to stop.