RIP Ben White

Ben White house
1972-2024

Mid-January 1988. A Washington real-estate developer with Kirk White for his lawyer handed our dad an envelope, after they finished talking about something. The envelope contained two tickets to Super Bowl XXII. [This is my eulogy at my brother’s funeral this past Saturday.]

Dad wasn’t exactly sure what to do. He had too much work and couldn’t travel anytime soon. And how could he take just one of us sons, and not the other, anyway?  He came home and pulled the envelope out of his jacket pocket and brandished the tickets in front of mom and Ben and me, presenting them as a kind of problem to be solved.

redskins-logoThe game would occur in San Diego, California. One of the teams was the Denver Broncos, with Dan Elway as the quarterback. The other team had Doug Williams. Back in those days, the name of that other team began with the letter R.

Anyone see the first Lord of the Rings movie? There’s a scene where they’re all sitting around, trying to figure out who will travel to Mordor to cast the Ring of Power into Mount Doom. There’s a lot of fretting about how much trouble it will be. Then the hobbits pipe up and say, “We’ll take it. We’ll take the ring!”

There weren’t any hobbits in the kitchen on McKinley Street. But we two high-school boys delivered the neighborhood newspapers every morning, and therefore had some airplane-ticket money in our pockets. “We’ll take the tickets!”

Now, a good number of people here knew Ann White. In fact, a considerable number of people here knew Ann White well enough to live in fear of the woman.

Ben me and mom

Ben convinced her. He convinced her to let us have the tickets, and to fly to California by ourselves. I did my part in the convincing, of course. I pledged my entire future that we would both be in our proper classrooms by the first bell the morning after the game. We would take the red-eye back at mightnight and get to school on time. Mom trusted me that far.

But Ben is the one who really convinced her to let us do it. He convinced the formidable Academic Dean of Edmund Burke School to make a decision that would probably get a parent arrested for reckless child endangerment these days. As we all know, Ben White knew how to make his excitement infectious. He saw a chance for something great. He stretched out his hand. He took you along.

We just heard from St. Paul about the groaning of creation. Creation groaning under the weight of apparent futility.

People suffer. People die. Ben suffered. Ben died. And now we suffer.

We all know a light in this world has gone out. A light of truth-seeking, love, fun, and kindness. A light so strong it had an intense force, an interior force that moved other things, by a power of will. When he got an idea in his head, Ben White had a will that could move a mountain.

Ben and Sara

Sports teams live by the enthusiasm of the fans. The Yankees will never win more than 80 games in a season ever again. The Washington Football Team might as well just hang it up completely. You know they even tweeted it out, on the official Commanders account? “We lost one of our most passionate.”

Indeed you did, Commanders. We all did. We have lost one of our most passionate.

Passionately in love with wisdom and truth. Passionately in love with Jacob and Rafi. [Please click here to make a donation to the college fund for the boys, if you can.] Passionately in love with Sara. Zealous for all his dear friends. Groaning with eagerness that all the ones he loved would be safe, and be happy, and thrive. He groaned with eagerness that everyone would be safe, and be happy, and thrive. Everyone. Everyone except Dan Snyder.

Well, and maybe everyone except one other person, too. My brother groaned with eagerness for the happiness and vitality of everyone around him. For himself? That was more complicated.

Thus we weep here today. Thus we groan here today.

Ben and me

…We grew up singing hymns, in our family. You might think to yourself, ‘I can’t quite picture Ben holding a hymnal and belting out divine praises like a choirboy.’ But he did it; we did it–every Sunday of our entire young lives. That’s what our family did, and I still do. And if you were at my mother’s funeral last fall, and paid attention to my brother, you saw him do it then. He sang out mommy’s favorite hymns. Benjamin White was about as Jewish-adjacent as you can get.* But he lived a died a Christian man.

This day has come way too soon. But Ben did make me promise that when the day of his funeral did come, that we would have our mother’s favorite hymn.

A mighty fortress is our God, a bulwark never failing;

our helper he, amid the flood of mortal ills prevailing.

For still our ancient foe does seek to work us woe;

his craft and power are great, and armed with cruel hate,

on earth is not his equal.

 

Did we in our own strength confide, our striving would be losing,

were not the right Man on our side, the Man of God’s own choosing.

You ask who that may be? Christ Jesus, it is he;

Lord Sabaoth his name, from age to age the same;

and he must win the battle.

 

______________________

* Ben has two Jewish sons, was married to two Jewish women at different times in his life, and died in love with a third.

Ann White, RIP

July 23, 1939 – September 29, 2023

We will have a reception and program in honor of Ann White on Thursday, October 19, at 6:00 p.m. at Edmund Burke School, 4101 Connecticut Ave., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20008.

We had her funeral here in Martinsville VA last week.

Mom planned her funeral carefully, ahead of time–including the hymns, readings, and speakers (my brother and me.) This was my reading and eulogy…

In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. He was in the beginning with God. All things came to be through him, and without him nothing came to be.

What came to be through him was life, and this life was the light of the human race; the light shines in the darkness, and the darkness has not overcome it.

John 1:1-5

The church bells were ringing in a small Irish town. A mother was banging on her grown son’s bedroom door. “Get up, for God’s sake!” From his bed, the son answered, “I have two reasons for not going. They don’t like me, and I don’t like them.”

The mother replied, “Yes, you are going. For two reasons. It’s time for Mass. And you’re the priest.”

In my case, I guess I would say,, “The bishop doesn’t like me. And I don’t like him.” Ann White did not particularly like the bishop, either.

But that doesn’t mean mom wasn’t churchy. When the young Ann White was in high school, she played hymns in church. She played hymns in our family home. She sang hymns with all her heart, her whole life long.

She also did a lot of teaching. She taught high-school history for a quarter century. At the Edmund Burke School in Washington, D.C., where she taught, there’s a room named after her, called “Ann’s Academy,” (students call teachers by their first names at Burke). A plaque on the wall reads, “In honor of Ann White, who taught over 15,000 classes here and opened generations of students’ minds to worlds of new ideas and perspectives.”

Mommy taught my brother Ben and me, too. She started with us. She was a demanding teacher in the classroom. Well-known for it. Imagine what it was like being us.

What did she teach us, all of us students of hers?

She taught us to sort sentimentality out of our minds, and keep careful, disciplined thought, based on verifiable facts. But to do the sorting not with cold severity, but with kindness and patience.

She taught us to keep our eyes and ears open for the small fun and funny things you can find around you, if you look for them.

She always found them. Like coffee ice-cream with chocolate chips, at a beach boardwalk ice-cream parlor. Or a pair of green socks with little goldfinches on them. 

Ann White laughed so contagiously for so many years because she had systematically flushed all pretense and grandiosity out of her mind and out of her life. And that left her surrounded with lovely, simple little pleasures. Like the hydrangea blossoms in the yard.

What else did she teach us? She taught us to ask questions.

And I don’t mean that abstractly, like a slogan. Question orthodoxy! Confront the power! Be a Free Thinker! No, that’s not what I mean when I say that Ann White taught her sons and her students to ask questions. No, she taught us literally to ask questions. When you’re having a conversation, ask questions. When you meet people, when you see people, when you open your mouth: Ask questions.

For Ann White, that’s what a conversation was. Asking another person questions. Wanting to know what the other person had inside him- or herself.

Our mother became just about the most fiercely beloved teacher in the history of Edmund Burke School. Because, though she did not mind talking, and telling the students important facts, she far preferred asking them questions and listening to their answers. She wanted, above all, to listen to her students say interesting, true things. She wanted to hear her students’ personal understanding of the historical facts that she had taught them.

Which brings us to the gospel passage I just read. The Word of God became flesh, full of grace and truth, full of infinite divine love, and He walked among us in ancient Israel. That is the all-important fact of history that mommy taught us in our home.

She never banged on our doors on Sunday mornings when the church bells were ringing. That is, at least not after we became grown men. But if we lollygagged in bed on Sunday mornings when we were in high school, she did pour ice water down our backs. Going to church was not optional in our family. I think she even poured Sunday-morning ice-water on dad a time or two. 

What came to be through the Word made flesh? Life. The life that is the light of the human race.

Here’s a question for us, as we stare at mommy’s coffin. What does death mean?

Does it mean that we will never see light in the eyes of this pretty woman again? This demanding, funny, hip, impatient, sweet, stylish woman. The best history teacher Edmund Burke School ever had? The best friend that I, for one, could ever hope to have?

If this coffin, and this service, and the burial we are about to do–if all that meant that her eyes are closed forever, I can honestly say that standing here right now would utterly destroy me.

But in our home, she insisted on us learning the Gospel. The Word of life became a wandering rabbi. We crucified Him. He rose again on the third day.

For Ben and me, there is silence now where mommy’s voice belongs. That silence is like the pounding of an enemy’s fists into our faces and torsos. The silence where the little >PING< of a text message from her belongs: a gut punch. Like Mike Tyson said, “Everyone has a plan. Until you get punched in the face.”

But: No, Death. Be not proud. The empty silence you rain down on us like blows–it will not outlast us. For my part, you’re dealing with a dude here who has run eight marathons, with a new artificial hip to show for it.

We will outlast your empty silence, Death. We will endure, and we will outlast it. With the same faith in the promises of Christ that Ann White taught us.

We read in the gospels that there came a time when the disciples stopped asking Jesus questions. And He stopped asking them questions. Silence descended upon them as Good Friday came. Then the Saturday sabbath gaped open, empty, and utterly silent. The Teacher was missing.

But it ended, the empty stillness. On Sunday, the hymns began.

We will see this woman again. She will have on a pair of lovely, interesting socks.

Undying light will fill the classroom. She will speak with us, gesturing with her hand like she always did, with light back in her loving eyes.

Worshiping and Venerating Images, the Blessed Mother, and Saints’ Relics

Should we worship the image of Christ as we worship the Creator?

ST III Q25 a3

Should we worship Christ’s cross as we worship the Creator?

ST III Q25 a4

Should we worship the Mother of God as we worship the Creator?

ST III Q25 a5

Should we venerate the relics of the saints?

ST III Q25 a6

[Click HERE for full podcast website]

NB.

latria = worship of the Creator

dulia = veneration of an angel or a fellow human being worthy of reverence