A Call to Liberty - Liberty Fund

Taxation Without Consent: An Enduring American Grievance?

An essay by Bobbi Herzberg

Many of the colonists’ complaints centered on unjust taxation. To what extent do those complaints continue to be relevant today?

Read More

Letter from the Editors

Under the auspices of tyranny the life of the subject is often sported with, and the fruits of his daily toil are consumed in oppressive taxes, that serve to gratify the ambition, avarice, and lusts of his superiors. Every court minion riots in the spoils of the honest laborer, and despises the hand by which he is fed. 

— Alexander Hamilton

Hamilton pulled no punches when it came to criticizing the taxes to which the American colonists were subject, and every year as we all fill out our 1040s, a little of this revolutionary sentiment arises in each of us. This month’s lead essayist, Bobbi Herzberg, draws some clear and careful connections between the tax policies the founders protested, and some current debates over taxation. Is the only real change between Hamilton’s day and our own the more efficient extraction of tax payments? Our pamphlet essayists, a group of economics students from Ball State University, headed up by their professor Nathanael Snow, pursue similar questions in relation to three pamphlets from the Jack Greene collection. Both essays will make fine reading as you prepare for April 15th.

This Month's Further Reading and Listening

As you delay completing your taxes, we offer some reflections on the nature of taxation, both in the eighteenth century and today, and the general questions the American Revolution continues to force us to confront. Mitch Daniels sits down with Lord Andrew Roberts to discuss George III and the power of political myths, Gordon Wood explains the colonists’ reaction to taxing tea, and three of our authors present different views of how government raises funds.

Countdown to the Declaration

New material every month as we explore the Declaration's past, present, and future.

3

months to go

Find the full list of months, including archived and upcoming themes, on our Countdown page.

We are a private educational foundation that encourages thought and discussion of enduring issues about liberty.

Liberty Fund offers a rich set of educational programs. These include Socratic-style conferences, thought-provoking books, and engaging online resources focused on the understanding and appreciation of the complex nature of a free and responsible society.