Nine stars
As Canada prepares for some turbulent times south of the border, it would be remiss not to talk about some of the political fallout within our own borders as well. An election is sure to occur by October 2025 and I wanted to do a little Election Prep for Canada, as I have done for US presidential elections in years past. We have a prime minister who has resigned due to some really poor polling numbers and a salivating Leader of the Opposition wanting to topple the tower right away for his own benefit. This entire experience could be extra fun, as there are whispers from on high in Washington that the upcoming election could be the last for Canada as a sovereign country before we become the 51st state. Let’s see where this reading journey takes us!
Stephen Maher delivers a wonderfully comprehensive biography of Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau. Pulling no punches and tapping into his vast knowledge and well-linked journalism, Maher effectively argues that Trudeau used his popular name to woo Liberals who were seeking to reinvent themselves and the party, rather than choose a well-grounded political figure. Working swiftly to gain favour, Trudeau was big on charisma and tried to show himself as new age and willing to work with the masses. However, once in power, Trudeau relied on others to do the leading while he basked in the glory. Refusing to accept pushback on his work, his senior advisors had to shove to ensure the PM got the answers he wanted or fudge the truth to make others look poorly. A well-documented book that I could not stop reading and quite apt at explaining the recent disintegration of a man whose name should have been enough to crown him victor for long periods. Maher delivers and keeps the reader well informed along the way!
From the outset, Justin Trudeau relied on his father’s reputation to garner support and success with Canadians and more specifically, the Liberal Party of Canada. Pierre Elliott Trudeau, one of Canada’s most well-known and policy-driven prime ministers, made quite the impact on the country he led from the late 1960s until the mid-80s. Stephen Maher begins the piece looking at the Trudeau family and their stardom that followed them for a number of reasons. Using his father’s name and connection to Canada, a younger Justin sought to make waves by running as a Member of Parliament, with likely aspirations of following in his father’s footsteps.
Maher examines this rise to power and how Trudeau was able to grab the reins, pushing political long-timers out of the way in order to create a snazzy new approach to politics and the Liberal brand when Justin ran for and win the party’s leadership. With that firmly established, it was time to eke out a victory of some sort, trying to resurrect a bumbling party from the basement back to power. With keen insights and seeking to curry favour with others, Trudeau made great inroads, using a star team and well-placed events to show Canadians he was there for them.
After pulling off a shocking win in the 2015 election, Justin Trudeau became prime minister and an international symbol for change. He was lauded around the world as being fresh and ready to work, with a photogenic family and ideas that flowed with ease. Trudeaumania was back, though perhaps not in the same way it had been for his father. Still, Justin sought to tackle many of the issues Canadians had, hoping to make a difference and ensure they were heard. As Maher argues, the honeymoon was long and drawn-out, with many ready to accept this new approach, so long as it garnered results. It did, for a time, as Trudeau stood up to the likes of Trump, the Chinese, and even some of his own detractors, but the rose-coloured glasses soon tinted things in other ways that Trudeau and the Liberals would not like.
In the latter portion of the book, Maher begins to examine the hidden issues that did not always make it into the public domain until the mid had been tossed. There are a few key events discussed where Trudeau was seen as pushing off his leadership roles with caucus and cabinet colleagues to others. Trudeau, an admitted introvert, would not enjoy one-on-one meetings, preferring to meet in larger groups where he could dilute his role. Save for fiery speeches directing people or rallying them to a cause, Trudeau wanted senior officials in the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) or bureaucrats to handle things. Those he did handle went sour quickly. He appeared to want to promote feminism and the indigenous population in Canada, but appears to have bullied his choice for Minister of Justice when she did not follow his directives, choosing to want the legal ramifications to play out. Other instances occurred when Trudeau and his first Minister of Finance differed on approaches, where speaking out against the views of the PM proved to be the kiss of death. Tie that into some international foibles and a poorly executed plan for COVID-19, which helped solidify the ongoing issues Trudeau had leading the country and keeping his party together.
Maher rounds out the discussion with some poignant analysis on the electoral woes of the Conservative Party of Canada, who were to be the largest thorns in the side of Trudeau. They failed to consolidate when needed and could not drum up enough support across the country to ensure a Liberal demise. Too fragmented, the party could not jump on many of the Liberal gaffes. mostly headlined by Trudeau himself. Extended COVID mandates, a truckers convoy that led to the use of the Emergencies Act, and even some ball dropping when it came to recognising the role Canada played in indigenous treatment. Nothing could or would work to dethrone Trudeau or those closest to him. However, there was something brewing and the nine lives Trudeau had were coming to an end. Added issues and an ongoing fracturing of the Liberal core in caucus and cabinet left many wondering if it was time for a change. Trudeau had lost his lustre, both at home and amongst the international community. It was not clear if he could get it back.
It appeared that arrogance and an infallibility complex left the prime minister unwilling to see the truth until it was too late and the knives had come out within his party. We shall soon see how it all plays out, as Trudeau has left the building, with a new leader (and prime minister) set to be chosen by the party soon, and an election on the horizon for later in 2025.
Stephen Maher does a formidable job with this piece, which elucidates not only the rise to power of Justin Trudeau, but also his slow and convincing fall from grace. In this well-documented biography, Maher presents a comprehensive history of Trudeau during a tumultuous period of Canadian politics. Drawing intriguing parallels between Trudeau and his father, the book is aptly titled, as Justin is surely the prince to his father’s political monarchy, though the reign was shorter and filled with more trapdoors, or so it would seem. Great chapters lead the reader through the story, from a young man who was trying to break from his father’s shadow through to the Canadian prime minister who relied too much on Canadians accepting his rule as completely without error. Narcissistic and demanding the utmost fidelity, Maher argues that Trudeau dug his own grave, especially when the Conservative Party found a leader able to tame his antics. Using numerous interviews and strong sentiments relayed in honest sentiments, Maher makes his points with ease and keeps the reader in the middle of the action. I can only hope that the next chapter in Canadian politics is just as intense!
Kudos, Mr. Maher, for this stunning look at the man many hoped would breathe new life into Canadian politics.
Like/hate the review? An ever-growing collection of others appears at:
https://pecheyponderings.wordpress.com/