Several months ago on NPR I was listening to a conversation about immigration and health care. One woman said something to the effect of, " I think it is a joke that people who aren't even citizens of this country can get on Medicaid. I don't want any of my tax dollars going towards those people."
I've been stewing over this comment for several weeks and seeing as yesterday was Human Rights Day here in the US I decided that it was a good time to put words to my thoughts.
First of all this woman's comment made me really angry. I realize that there are people, citizens and non-citizens, who take advantage of the welfare system but I think that majority of the people who are using the resources really need them. In my opinion things like education, decent housing, food, and adequate health care are basic human rights that every person, regardless of citizenship status, nationality, language or ability is entitled to have. I believe it is our responsibility as fellow human beings, and children of God, to make sure that others have the same opportunities that we do and aren't denied basic human rights because of poverty or nationality.
Article 25 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights says:
- Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family, including food, clothing, housing and medical care and necessary social services, and the right to security in the event of unemployment, sickness, disability, widowhood, old age or other lack of livelihood in circumstances beyond his control.
- (2) Motherhood and childhood are entitled to special care and assistance. All children, whether born in or out of wedlock, shall enjoy the same social protection.
I think I feel so strongly about this because not only am I personally uninsured right now because we can't afford health insurance for me (the option my husband gets through his school would cost more than our house payment a month and a private plan with the most lousy coverage...10,000+ deductible... would cost me $150 a month) but also because I've had someone very near and dear to me hit rock bottom and almost become homeless. She needed mental health care desperately and as I struggled to find some way to help her I realized that even though we have lots of government programs they have holes in them and there are many people who become homeless or poverty stricken because they fall through the gaps in our program coverage. I realized that for those who are at "rock bottom" it really takes some sort of miracle to help them get back on their feet because our programs don't do nearly enough. Luckily, my loved one got a miracle and after going through all that with her I now have NO problem paying taxes that support programs like food stamps, subsidized housing, medicaid and WIC because I know that there are people who really really need them.
I get a little discouraged when health care legislation gets "hung up" because people start throwing the word "socialized" around as a scare tactic. Personally I would have no problem with a "socialized medical" system because I think that it would ensure that all people would have some sort of access to medical care. We have a socialized education system and Americans don't really seem to mind that. True, our public education isn't always the best but I think that most Americans would agree that it is better to have some sort of universal education system in place than none at all. Any sort of education gives people a chance at a better life and develops them as people, and the rich will always be able to afford something better if they aren't satisfied with the public option.
Imagine what the US would be like today if people were only educated if they could pay for it. What sort of electorate would we have? How many more social problems would we have? How much bigger the gap between the rich and the poor would be? It is kind of a scary picture. Americans have already accepted the fact that education is a basic human right and can see that our country is better because all people are able to receive an education. When are we going to realize that health care is a basic human right and our country would be better if all people were able to receive health care, not just those that can afford it?
This is a topic that really hits a nerve in my spirit and I don't think that as Americans we can consider ourselves a "civilized" or "Christian" nation when we don't take care of our sick, our poor, and our disabled. So this Human Rights Day I said a little prayer that sometime in the very near future that somehow our government and people will find a way to fill in all the gaps and wake up to our responsibility as human beings to provide our brothers and sisters with the basic human rights they deserve.
Also if anyone knows of a good way for me to find affordable health insurance, that doesn't involve me getting pregnant so I can qualify for Medicaid, please let me know!
















